Skip to content

Written by Online therapist Dr. Gloria Vanderhorst, Ph.D.

WHERE DO OUR IDEAS ABOUT MASCULINITY COME FROM?

Unlearning What We Inherited and Making Space for Emotional Truth About Masculinity

We rarely stop to ask where our ideas about masculinity actually come from.

We inherit them, from family, from culture, from school, from silence, from what was rewarded and what was discouraged.

I joined The James Finochio Show for a conversation that goes straight to the root question: Who told us what a man should be, and what happens when that definition leaves no room for emotional truth?

With over fifty years of clinical experience, I’ve seen the same pattern again and again in boys and men across generations: emotional suppression that begins early, is reinforced socially, and eventually becomes internal identity.

This episode explores what that actually looks like in real life, and what it costs.

In this conversation, we discuss:

  • How boys begin learning emotional restriction in early childhood
  • Why anger is often the only “allowed” emotion for men
  • What gets pushed down when sadness, fear, or vulnerability are not accepted
  • How parenting and culture shape emotional development over time
  • Why many men feel disconnected from their own internal experience
  • The long‑term impact of emotional suppression on relationships
  • What changes when men are finally given permission to feel

One of the core truths in this episode is simple:

Much of what we call “masculinity” is learned behavior, not inherent identity.
And anything learned can be re‑examined.

This is not about blaming individuals. It is about understanding systems, and recognizing that many men are carrying emotional limitations they never consciously chose.

When we shift the question from “What is wrong with men?” to “What were men taught?” the entire conversation changes.

🎧 Watch the full episode:
The James Finochio Show – Full Conversation

For more reflections on emotional development, masculinity, and the psychology of learned patterns, explore articles on Psychology Today and research from Greater Good Science Center.

If you or someone you love is navigating questions about identity, emotional expression, or long‑standing patterns learned in childhood, therapy can help create space for clarity and change. Learn more about individual therapy in Maryland and DC or explore therapeutic approaches that support emotional insight, healing, and growth.

With appreciation,
Dr. Gloria Vanderhorst

related blog post by Dr. Gloria Vanderhorst, Ph.D.

Read more of my stories and reflections

summer friends, two boys discovering the power of playing games and speaking while a parent watches patiently, symbolizing raising Boys’ Emotional Development, of boys cry, and emotional disconnection in Maryland and DC.

Summer Friends | A Reflection on Camp Adventures and Short‑Term Bonds

The Magic of Summer Friends, the Camp, the Adventure of Youth, and the Sweetness of Short‑Term Bonds Remember camp? What an adventure! What was yours like? One version is rustic. The cabins are made of old logs, and you can write on the walls to your heart’s content. Each cabin
Read My Post
Participants engaged in active listening during mediation thinking about while change feels hard during childhood, illustrating brain wiring, Emotional Healing, and mediation skills in online therapy in Maryland and DC.

I Scream, You Scream | A Reflection on Ice Cream Memories and Summer Joy

I Scream – The Sweet Treat That Unlocks a Lifetime of Summer Memories Raise your hand if you recognize this! In 1927, this little ditty became a classic and a tongue-twister challenge. For me, it brings back great memories associated with this summer treat. My grandmother’s ice cream churn would
Read My Post
A woman studying on round table next to appliances which Influences Connection and Conversation , symbolizing compassion and the origins of civilization in Maryland and DC.

How Table Shape Influences Connection and Conversation

How the Shape of a Table Shapes the Way We Relate and Influence Connection and Conversation Have you ever paused to consider why some tables are round and others are rectangular? My parents grew up in farming communities where long rectangular tables were the norm — the kind you’d see
Read My Post
A woman drawn to reflect the soul with a pink sunset on July 4th, symbolizing gender norms, Dolly Parton, and emotional reflection and in Maryland and DC.

Dolly Parton | A Reflection on Faith, Service, and Lifelong Values

Dolly’s Life of Sparkle, Service, and Unshakeable Values The celebration of this life is truly appropriate. She was an unusual woman. When poverty is your beginning, you do not tend to go far. The faith of her family was both an anchor and a hope. One cannot discount the importance
Read My Post